EN
Side by side

Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl vs Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent

Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl Eau de Parfum perfume bottleCarolina HerreraCh Good GirlEau de Parfum · 2016Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent Eau de Parfum perfume bottleYves Saint LaurentManifesto Yves Saint LaurentEau de Parfum · 2012
Quick answer

Do Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl and Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent smell the same?

Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl and Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent share 6 notes: bergamot, jasmine sambac, tonka bean, vanilla, sandalwood and cedar. Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl smells mostly sweet and white floral. Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent smells mostly vanilla and gourmand. Both last about as long. Both are about as strong. Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent costs less, from €16.

Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl on AmazonYves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, iPerfume earns from qualifying purchases.

Quick comparison

Quick comparisonCarolina Herrera Ch Good GirlYves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent
BrandCarolina HerreraYves Saint Laurent
StrengthEau de ParfumEau de Parfum
Year20162012
ForFor womenFor women
Family--
Main accordsSweet, White floral, GourmandVanilla, Gourmand, Woody
Lasts6 to 9 hours6 to 9 hours
Strength of scentStrongStrong
Best seasonwinter and fallwinter and fall
Priceabout €72about €16
Rating3.964.09

Notes compared

Only in Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl

Notes in both

Only in Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent

Main accords compared

Carolina Herrera Ch Good GirlYves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent
Sweet
100% / 55%
White floral
100% / 55%
Gourmand
100% / 100%
Warm spicy
100% / 55%
Vanilla
100% / 100%
Amber
75% / 55%
Woody
75% / 75%
Fruity
0% / 55%

Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl vs Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent: questions

Which lasts longer, Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl or Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent?

Both last about as long. Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl: 6 to 9 hours. Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent: 6 to 9 hours.

Do Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl and Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent smell the same?

No, they are two different perfumes. Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl and Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent share 6 notes: bergamot, jasmine sambac, tonka bean, vanilla, sandalwood and cedar. Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl smells mostly sweet and white floral. Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent smells mostly vanilla and gourmand.

Which is cheaper, Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl or Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent?

Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent costs less, from €16. Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl: about €72. Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent: about €16.

Which is better for summer, Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl or Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent?

Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent is the better pick for summer.

All about Carolina Herrera Ch Good Girl All about Yves Saint Laurent Manifesto Yves Saint Laurent Perfume comparisons